A Tale of Two Instruments: Re-Tipping vs. Replacing

Every dental hygienist has been there: you reach for your go-to scaler, only to realize it’s lost its edge. The question now becomes, do you replace it entirely, or is it time to re-tip?

At first glance, replacing may seem like the most straightforward option. But when you dig deeper into the cost, quality, environmental impact, and longevity, the choice isn’t always so clear-cut.

Let’s break it down.

1. Cost: What Are You Really Paying For?

New instruments can range from $60 to $100 or more each. Multiply that across a full setup and the costs add up fast.

Re-tipping, on the other hand, offers a budget-friendly alternative. At Progressive Edge, re-tipping allows you to keep your favourite handles and simply replace the working end, at a fraction of the cost of buying new.

Savings Snapshot:

• Buying new: $80 per instrument

• Re-tipping: ~$25 per instrument

• Savings: Up to 65%

That’s real money back in your clinic’s pocket without compromising on performance.

2. Quality: Do Re-Tipped Instruments Perform the Same?

A common myth is that re-tipped instruments don’t match the quality of new ones. The truth? When done properly by a trusted provider, re-tipped instruments are just as effective.

At Progressive Edge, we use high-grade stainless steel tips that are expertly bonded to the original handle. The result is an instrument that looks, feels, and performs like new.

Re-tipping also allows you to hold onto the handles you already love, especially helpful if you have ergonomic grips or lightweight designs you don’t want to part with.

3. Environmental Impact: Reduce Waste, Retip Responsibly

Instruments may be small, but the waste from discarded scalers adds up over time.

Choosing to re-tip is a sustainable choice that reduces landfill waste and conserves resources. By extending the life of your existing handles, you’re lowering your clinic’s environmental footprint without compromising care.

It’s a simple shift with a powerful impact, especially for offices looking to adopt more eco-conscious practices.

4. Longevity: How Long Will Each Option Last?

A brand-new instrument will have the longest lifespan overall, but a properly re-tipped instrument can be re-sharpened and re-used multiple times before needing replacement.

If your handles are still in good condition, re-tipping gives you many of the same benefits of new without the full replacement cost. And when re-tipping is done correctly, the bond is secure and durable enough to withstand sterilization cycles and daily clinical use.

So… What’s the Verdict?

Replacing might be the right call when:

• Your handle is damaged or showing signs of wear

• You want to try a new shape, brand, or grip

• The cost is not a concern

We also sell new btw…. click here! 

Re-tipping is the smart move when:

• You want to save money without sacrificing quality

• Your current handles are in good condition

• You’re looking for a more sustainable solution

Re-tipping and replacing both have their place, but in many cases, re-tipping is the unsung hero. It’s affordable, effective, and environmentally conscious, plus, it gives your favourite instruments a second life.

At Progressive Edge, we specialize in high-quality re-tipping that Canadian hygienists can trust. Our turnaround times are quick, our materials are top-tier, and our customer service speaks for itself.

Ready to give your instruments a fresh start?

Explore our re-tipping service and see how much you can save.
Learn more about re-tipping with Progressive Edge → https://progressiveedge.ca/services/retipping